Skip to main content

Mutrux Firm Injury Lawyers

Missouri Car Accident Punitive Damages Lawyer

U.S. Army veteran and former State Farm claims representative, now fighting for injured people. Licensed in Missouri, Illinois and U.S. Federal Courts. No fees unless we win!

5-Star Rated on Google
Find Out if You Have a Case
Table of Contents

    How Do Punitive Damages Work in a Missouri Car Accident Case?

    Most car accident claims are about making the injured person whole: paying for medical care, lost income, and the pain the crash caused. Those are compensatory damages, and you can read more about them on our recoverable damages page. Some crashes, though, are caused by conduct so dangerous that paying the victim's losses does not seem like enough. In those cases, Missouri law allows a jury to add punitive damages, an extra award meant to punish the at-fault driver and warn others not to do the same thing.

    Punitive damages are rare, and Missouri makes them hard to get. When the facts support them, though, they can change how seriously an insurance company and a defense lawyer treat your case. Schedule a free consultation to talk about whether your crash may qualify.

    What Must You Prove to Get Punitive Damages in Missouri?

    Missouri tightened its punitive damages law in 2020. Under RSMo 510.261, a jury can award punitive damages only if you prove, by clear and convincing evidence, that the defendant either:

    • Intentionally harmed you without just cause, or
    • Acted with a deliberate and flagrant disregard for the safety of others.

    "Clear and convincing" is a higher bar than the "more likely than not" standard used for the rest of an injury case. A driver who simply ran a stop sign or followed too closely was careless, and careless driving alone usually will not support punitive damages. The evidence has to show the driver knew the risk and chose to ignore it.

    What Kinds of Driver Conduct Can Lead to Punitive Damages?

    Every case turns on its own facts, but these situations come up most often:

    • Drunk or drugged driving, especially with a very high blood alcohol level or prior impaired-driving offenses
    • Extreme speeding or street racing, such as driving far over the limit through a residential area
    • Fleeing police and causing a crash during the chase
    • Hit-and-run, depending on the circumstances surrounding the crash and the driver's conduct
    • Trucking company violations, such as knowingly pushing a driver past federal hours-of-service limits or keeping a driver with a dangerous record behind the wheel

    Texting or other distracted driving can be part of the picture, but on its own it is often treated as negligence. What usually makes the difference is evidence of a conscious choice to take a serious risk.

    How Do Punitive Damages Relate to Economic and Non-Economic Damages?

    They are separate awards, but they are connected. Economic damages cover losses with a dollar figure, such as medical bills and lost wages. Non-economic damages cover harms like pain, suffering, and loss of enjoyment of life. Punitive damages are not meant to repay any of those losses; they are based on how bad the defendant's conduct was.

    The connection shows up in the numbers. Missouri's statutory limit on punitive damages is tied to the net judgment for your other damages (more on that below), and the jury decides your compensatory damages before it ever reaches the punitive amount. Your lawyer cannot set the punitive figure. The jury decides it, based on the evidence and the defendant's conduct.

    How Does a Punitive Damages Claim Move Through a Missouri Court?

    1. The lawsuit is filed without a punitive claim. Missouri does not allow a request for punitive damages in the first petition (RSMo 510.261).
    2. Evidence is gathered. Police reports, toxicology results, phone records, vehicle data, and witness testimony are collected through investigation and discovery.
    3. Your lawyer asks the court for permission. A written motion, backed by affidavits, exhibits, or discovery, must be filed at least 120 days before the final pretrial conference, or before trial if none is set. The judge allows the claim only if a jury could reasonably find the clear and convincing standard is met.
    4. The trial may be split into two stages. If either side asks, the jury first decides fault, compensatory damages, and whether punitive damages are warranted. Only then does it hear evidence about the defendant's net worth and set the punitive amount (RSMo 510.263).

    Because of the 120-day deadline, the evidence has to be found early. Waiting can mean losing the chance to ask for punitive damages at all.

    Is There a Limit on Punitive Damages in Missouri?

    Missouri law caps punitive damages at $500,000 or five times the net judgment, whichever is greater (RSMo 510.265). The cap does not apply when the defendant pleads guilty to or is convicted of a felony arising from the same conduct, which can matter in serious drunk driving cases. The Missouri Supreme Court has also held that the cap cannot be applied to certain common-law claims, so whether it limits a particular award depends on the type of claim.

    There is one more rule many people don't know about. Under RSMo 537.675, the State of Missouri takes 50% of a final punitive damages judgment, after attorney's fees and expenses, for the Tort Victims' Compensation Fund. That lien applies only to the punitive portion, not to your compensatory damages.

    Can a Company Be Liable for Punitive Damages for Its Driver?

    Sometimes. When a delivery driver, truck driver, or other employee causes a crash, the employer usually pays the compensatory damages. Punitive damages against the company are harder. Under RSMo 510.261, they are available only if the company authorized or ratified the conduct, was reckless in hiring or keeping an unfit driver, or the driver was a manager acting within the scope of the job. That is why we look closely at hiring files, driving records, safety logs, and dispatch records in commercial vehicle cases.

    Where Are St. Louis County Punitive Damages Cases Tried?

    Missouri's venue law generally sends a car accident case to the county where the injury first happened (RSMo 508.010). For crashes in St. Louis County, that is usually the Circuit Court of St. Louis County, the 21st Judicial Circuit, at 105 S. Central Avenue in Clayton. Our office is on the same street. The same Missouri punitive damages rules apply in the City of St. Louis, Columbia, Kansas City, and every other county in the state.

    What If the Crash Happened in Illinois?

    Illinois handles punitive damages differently. In negligence cases, an Illinois complaint cannot ask for punitive damages at first; the plaintiff must file a motion and show a reasonable likelihood of proving facts at trial that support them (735 ILCS 5/2-604.1). Illinois has no cap like Missouri's, and its wrongful death law generally does not allow punitive damages. Tyson Mutrux is licensed in both Missouri and Illinois, so we can review which state's rules apply to your crash.

    How Does Mutrux Firm Injury Lawyers Build a Punitive Damages Case?

    Punitive damages are won or lost on evidence, and much of it disappears fast. From the first call, we work to:

    • Get the crash report, body camera and dash camera video, and any 911 recordings
    • Obtain blood alcohol or drug test results and the criminal case file, if charges were filed
    • Check the driver's prior traffic and impaired-driving record
    • Preserve vehicle event data, phone records, and nearby surveillance video
    • In commercial cases, request driver logs, hiring files, and the company's safety history

    Tyson Mutrux spent the early part of his career evaluating claims for State Farm, so he understands how insurers weigh the risk of a punitive damages verdict. We prepare every case as if it will be tried in front of a jury, because that is what a punitive damages claim may require.

    Talk to a Missouri Car Accident Lawyer About Punitive Damages

    If you were hurt by a drunk, reckless, or dangerous driver, call (314) 270-2273 or (888) 550-4026, or send us a message. Talking with us costs nothing, and there is no attorney's fee unless we win your case.

    This page is general information about Missouri and Illinois law, not legal advice. Every case depends on its own facts, and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

    Hit by a Drunk or Reckless Driver? Talk to a Missouri Car Accident Lawyer Today

    Have you been injured because of a car accident, truck crash, bus crash or by other negligent acts of another? Our Missouri and Illinois Injury Lawyers can help you!

    FAQ

    Find answers to common questions about Punitive damages

    What are punitive damages in a Missouri car accident case?

    Punitive damages are money awarded to punish a driver for especially bad conduct and to discourage others from doing the same. They are separate from compensatory damages, which pay for your medical bills, lost wages and pain and suffering. Most car accident cases involve only compensatory damages.

    When can you get punitive damages after a car accident in Missouri?

    Only in serious cases. Under RSMo 510.261, you must prove by clear and convincing evidence that the driver intentionally harmed you without just cause or acted with a deliberate and flagrant disregard for the safety of others. Ordinary carelessness, like a simple rear-end crash, is not enough.

    Can a drunk driving crash lead to punitive damages?

    It can. Driving while heavily intoxicated, racing, or speeding far over the limit may show a deliberate and flagrant disregard for others' safety. Whether punitive damages are allowed depends on the evidence in your case, such as the driver's blood alcohol level, prior offenses and how the crash happened.

    Can I ask for punitive damages when I first file my lawsuit?

    No. Missouri does not allow a punitive damages claim in the first petition. Your lawyer must later ask the court for permission with a written motion backed by evidence, and the judge decides whether a jury could reasonably find the clear and convincing standard is met (RSMo 510.261). That is why early investigation matters.

    Is there a cap on punitive damages in Missouri?

    Missouri law limits punitive damages to $500,000 or five times the net judgment, whichever is greater (RSMo 510.265). The cap does not apply if the defendant pleads guilty to or is convicted of a felony for the same conduct, and the Missouri Supreme Court has held it cannot be applied to some common-law claims. Whether it applies depends on the claim.

    Does a criminal conviction help my punitive damages claim?

    It can. A criminal case and your civil case are separate, but a felony guilty plea or conviction for the conduct that caused the crash removes the statutory cap on punitive damages (RSMo 510.265). Evidence from the criminal case, such as police reports and test results, can also support your civil claim.

    Do I keep the whole punitive damages award?

    Not all of it. Under RSMo 537.675, the State of Missouri has a lien on 50% of a final punitive damages judgment, after attorney's fees and expenses, for the Tort Victims' Compensation Fund. Compensatory damages are not subject to that lien.

    Can a trucking company or employer be made to pay punitive damages?

    Only in limited situations. Under RSMo 510.261, an employer can face punitive damages for a driver's conduct if it authorized or approved the act, recklessly hired or kept an unfit driver, or the driver was acting as a manager. That makes the company's hiring, training and safety records important evidence.

    Are punitive damages rules the same everywhere in Missouri?

    Yes. The standard of proof, the pleading rules and the cap come from state statutes, so they apply in St. Louis County, the City of St. Louis, Columbia, Kansas City and the rest of Missouri. What changes from county to county is the courthouse and the local jury that hears the case.

    How long do I have to file a Missouri car accident lawsuit that may include punitive damages?

    The punitive damages request is part of your injury lawsuit, so the same deadline applies. Most Missouri personal injury suits must be filed within five years (RSMo 516.120). If the crash was fatal, a wrongful death suit generally must be filed within three years (RSMo 537.100).

    Can a family get extra damages in a Missouri wrongful death case caused by a reckless driver?

    Yes. Missouri's wrongful death statute lets the jury consider aggravating circumstances surrounding the death, such as drunk or reckless driving (RSMo 537.090). These damages work much like punitive damages and are meant to address especially bad conduct.

    Who is the best lawyer for a punitive damages car accident case in St. Louis County?

    Look for a lawyer who investigates early, knows Missouri's strict rules for pleading punitive damages, and is ready to take the case to a St. Louis County jury. Tyson Mutrux knows how insurers react to these claims from his years as a State Farm claims representative. Mutrux Firm Injury Lawyers is in Clayton, near the St. Louis County courthouse.

    How much does it cost to hire Mutrux Firm Injury Lawyers?

    Nothing up front. We work on a contingency fee explained in writing before you sign, your first consultation is free, and there is no attorney's fee unless we win.