Skip to main content

Mutrux Firm Injury Lawyers

Personal Injury Settlement Lawyer

U.S. Army veteran and former State Farm claims representative, now fighting for injured people. Licensed in Missouri, Illinois and U.S. Federal Courts. No fees unless we win!

5-Star Rated on Google
Find Out if You Have a Case
Illustration of a plain white semi tractor-trailer driving on a multi-lane urban interstate in late afternoon light, with an overpass and a city skyline in the distance

Suing the Trucking Company: Negligent Hiring and CDL Qualification in Missouri

Illustration of a plain white semi tractor-trailer driving on a multi-lane urban interstate in late afternoon light, with an overpass and a city skyline in the distance
Behind every truck on the interstate is a company that decided who gets to drive it. (Illustration.)

Short answer: After a semi crash in Missouri, you can usually go after the trucking company two ways. The first is vicarious liability, called respondeat superior: the company answers for its driver’s carelessness on the job. The second is the company’s own carelessness: negligent hiring, negligent retention, negligent supervision, or negligent entrustment. Missouri adds a twist. Under McHaffie v. Bunch (Mo. banc 1995), once the company admits its driver was working within the scope of the job, the injured person generally can’t also take negligent hiring or entrustment theories to the jury, or put on evidence for them, unless there’s a valid punitive damages claim. Since 2020, Missouri’s punitive damages statute, RSMo 510.261, sets the rules for that, and it still lets you get the driver’s employment and qualification records when the company admits liability. That’s where the driver qualification file required by 49 CFR 391.51 comes in. It’s often the clearest record of what the company knew before it handed over the keys.

Why this question is in the news

On November 9, 2026, a semi crashed into traffic on U.S. 71 in Kansas City. Three people were killed, according to news reports. The driver has been criminally charged. Those are allegations, and no court has ruled on them.

Since then, the questions have turned to the license and the company. As reported by OTR News on November 14, U.S. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said FMCSA had identified the carrier and opened an investigation into that company and into how Illinois issued the driver’s commercial driver’s license. As of that report, the carrier hadn’t been named publicly and no results had been released.

On November 13, Missouri Gov. Mike Kehoe sent a letter to Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker urging Illinois to review its commercial licensing procedures, KCTV5 reported. Gov. Pritzker’s office responded in a statement to KCTV5.

We’re not going to referee the politics, and we don’t know what the federal investigation will find. What we can tell you is how these questions work in a civil case, because the same ones come up after a lot of serious truck crashes in Missouri. Who hired this driver? What did they check? And what did they know?

The FMCSA non-domiciled CDL rule, in plain English

Under 49 CFR 383.5, a non-domiciled CDL is a commercial license a state issues to someone who isn’t domiciled in that state, either because the person is domiciled in a foreign country or, in limited cases, in another state. FMCSA tightened the rules for those licenses in a final rule titled “Restoring Integrity to the Issuance of Non-Domiciled Commercial Drivers Licenses (CDL).” It was published in the Federal Register on February 13, 2026 (91 FR 7044) and took effect March 16, 2026.

According to FMCSA’s guidance on the final rule, only applicants who provide evidence of lawful immigration status in one of three employment-based categories can get a non-domiciled commercial learner’s permit or CDL: H-2A (temporary agricultural workers), H-2B (temporary non-agricultural workers), or E-2 (treaty investors).

That rule is aimed at state licensing agencies. It changes the rules in 49 CFR Parts 383 and 384 for who a state may license. It doesn’t, on its own, tell you whether a trucking company was careless. For that, you look at the rules that apply to the company.

What a trucking company has to check before a driver gets behind the wheel

A license is the floor, not the finish line. Federal rules put their own duties on the motor carrier.

The driver has to be qualified. Under 49 CFR 391.11(a), a motor carrier “shall not require or permit a person to drive a commercial motor vehicle unless that person is qualified.” Among other things, 391.11(b) requires the driver to be at least 21, to be able to safely operate the type of truck “by reason of experience, training, or both,” to be physically qualified, to hold a valid commercial license issued by only one state, to not be disqualified, and to have passed a road test or an accepted equivalent.

The company has to look at the driver’s history. Under 49 CFR 391.23, within 30 days of hiring, the carrier must ask each state where the driver held a license in the past 3 years for the driver’s motor vehicle record. It also has to investigate the driver’s safety performance history with DOT-regulated employers over the past 3 years.

The company has to check the drug and alcohol Clearinghouse. Under 49 CFR 382.701, an employer can’t put a driver subject to testing into a safety-sensitive job without first running a pre-employment query of FMCSA’s Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse, and it has to query at least once a year after that.

And it has to keep checking. Under 49 CFR 391.25, at least once every 12 months, the carrier has to pull each driver’s motor vehicle record and review it to decide whether the driver still meets minimum safe-driving requirements.

The driver qualification file: the paper trail on the hire

All of that is supposed to end up somewhere. Under 49 CFR 391.51, every motor carrier has to keep a driver qualification file, or DQ file, for every driver it employs. Among other items, the regulation says the file must include:

  • the driver’s employment application (49 CFR 391.21),
  • the motor vehicle record from each state licensing agency at hiring,
  • the road test certificate, or the license or certificate the carrier accepted instead,
  • the motor vehicle record from each annual inquiry,
  • a note about the annual review of the driver’s record,
  • the medical examiner’s certificate (or, for CDL holders, the state driving record showing medical certification status), and
  • any FMCSA medical variance or skill performance evaluation certificate.

The carrier has to keep the file for as long as the driver works there and for 3 years after (391.51(c)). Some items, like the annual driving records and medical certificates, can be pulled 3 years after they were created (391.51(d)).

Overhead view of an open manila folder on a wooden desk holding an employment application, a driving record, a medical examiner's certificate, and a road test certificate, with a pen and reading glasses nearby
The DQ file is supposed to show what the company knew about a driver before the crash, not after. (Illustration.)

Here’s why we care about this file so much. A DQ file tells a story. Sometimes it’s a clean story. Sometimes it shows a company that hired a driver with a bad record and never looked, or kept a driver after the warnings piled up, or has a file with holes where the required records should be. A missing annual review isn’t proof the company caused your crash. But it’s a question the company has to answer.

The DQ file isn’t the only record that matters. Driving logs and electronic logging device data can show hours and fatigue. We cover that in our post on truck ELD records in a Missouri accident lawsuit.

Negligent hiring, negligent retention, and negligent entrustment: what they are

These are claims about the company’s own conduct, not just the driver’s.

  • Negligent hiring. The Missouri Supreme Court described it in McHaffie: liability “turns on whether there are facts from which the employer knew or should have known of a particular dangerous proclivity of an employee followed by employee misconduct consistent with such dangerous proclivity.” In the same opinion, the court noted it’s “at least arguable” that Missouri negligent hiring requires intentional or criminal misconduct or a special relationship. That’s one reason truck cases often lean on negligent entrustment instead.
  • Negligent retention. Same idea, later in time. The company learned the driver was dangerous and kept him on the road anyway.
  • Negligent supervision or training. The company didn’t train or watch its driver the way a careful carrier would.
  • Negligent entrustment. The company let someone it knew, or should have known, was incompetent drive its vehicle. In Midwest Trust Co. v. United Parcel Service (Mo. App. W.D. 2025), the jury was told it had to find the company permitted the driver to operate its vehicle, the driver was incompetent to do so, the company knew or in the exercise of ordinary care should have known that, the company was negligent in permitting it, and the driver’s negligent driving caused the collision.

Notice the last part. Every one of these still requires the driver to have done something wrong that caused the crash. A bad hire who drives perfectly that day doesn’t create a claim.

How these claims differ from vicarious liability

Vicarious liability doesn’t care what the company did. If the driver was an employee or agent acting “within the course and scope of the employment,” the company is liable for the driver’s negligence (McHaffie, citing Burks v. Leap). Our post on employer liability after a crash with a company vehicle covers that piece.

Negligent hiring, retention, and entrustment are about the company’s own choices. In most cases they’re pleaded side by side with vicarious liability. The trouble starts when the company stands up and says, “Fine. He was ours. He was working.”

What happens when the company admits the driver was working (McHaffie)?

In McHaffie v. Bunch, 891 S.W.2d 822 (Mo. banc 1995), the Missouri Supreme Court adopted what it called the majority view: “once an employer has admitted respondeat superior liability for a driver’s negligence, it is improper to allow a plaintiff to proceed against the employer on any other theory of imputed liability.”

The court’s reasoning was that once the company admits it’s on the hook for the driver, “the liability of the employer is fixed by the amount of liability of the employee.” More theories don’t add more money. They just add evidence, which the court called “potentially inflammatory” and “irrelevant to any contested issue.” So the court held it was error to let the jury assess separate fault against the company for negligent hiring or entrustment, and error to admit evidence on those theories.

That’s why trucking companies admit agency early. It can keep a jury from ever seeing the driver’s file.

But McHaffie left doors open. The court said it “may be possible” to hold an employer liable on a theory “that does not derive from and is not dependent on the negligence” of the employee, and “possible that an employer or an entrustor may be liable for punitive damages which would not be assessed against the employee.” Missouri appellate courts have since walked through that second door:

  • In Wilson v. Image Flooring, LLC, 400 S.W.3d 386 (Mo. App. W.D. 2013), the Western District held there is a punitive damages exception to McHaffie, and that a plaintiff has to plead facts supporting punitive damages to use it.
  • In Midwest Trust Co. v. UPS, decided May 20, 2025, the Western District applied that exception. UPS had admitted its driver was acting in the course and scope of his job, but the trial court still allowed a negligent entrustment claim and evidence supporting punitive damages, and the court of appeals affirmed the evidence ruling.

Missouri’s 2020 punitive damages law (RSMo 510.261)

In 2020, the legislature passed Senate Bill 591, which created RSMo 510.261. It applies to causes of action filed on or after August 28, 2020 (RSMo 510.262). For a truck case against a company, a few parts matter most:

  • The standard is high. Punitive damages require clear and convincing evidence that the defendant “intentionally harmed the plaintiff without just cause or acted with a deliberate and flagrant disregard for the safety of others” (510.261.1).
  • Company liability for punitives is limited. Punitive damages can be awarded against an employer for an agent’s act only in listed situations. One of them is where “the agent was unfit and the principal or a managerial agent of the principal was reckless in employing or retaining him or her” (510.261.3(2)).
  • You can still get the hiring records. When an employer admits liability for its agent in a claim for compensatory damages, “the court shall grant limited discovery consisting only of employment records and documents or information related to the agent’s qualifications” (510.261.4). The DQ file fits that description.
  • You can’t start with it. A petition can’t include a punitive damages claim at the start. You need leave of court, on a motion filed at least 120 days before the final pretrial conference (or before trial if there isn’t one), supported by evidence showing a reasonable basis for punitive damages (510.261.5).

Put it together. If the company admits its driver was on the job, the fight over negligent hiring usually becomes a fight over whether the records show something bad enough to support punitive damages. You find that out from the file.

What to do if a trucking company’s driver hurt you or killed someone you love

  • Get the names right. The driver, the motor carrier, the USDOT number, the truck and trailer numbers. The company on the door isn’t always the carrier responsible.
  • Send a preservation letter fast. The DQ file has long retention rules, but the logging data, camera footage, and electronic engine data don’t.
  • Don’t assume the license settles anything. A valid license doesn’t prove the company did its job. An improperly issued one doesn’t automatically prove the company knew.
  • Watch the deadlines. Most Missouri personal injury claims must be filed within five years under RSMo 516.120. Wrongful death claims generally have a three-year deadline under RSMo 537.100.

Our offices are in St. Louis and Columbia. See our St. Louis truck accident, Columbia truck accident, and Missouri truck accident pages. If you lost a family member, see our St. Louis wrongful death lawyer page.

Frequently asked questions

Can I sue a trucking company for negligent hiring in Missouri?

Yes, Missouri recognizes negligent hiring, retention, supervision, and entrustment claims against employers. But under McHaffie v. Bunch, 891 S.W.2d 822 (Mo. banc 1995), once the company admits its driver was acting within the course and scope of employment, those theories generally can’t go to the jury, and evidence on them generally isn’t admitted, unless there’s a valid punitive damages claim. Missouri appellate courts recognized that punitive damages exception in Wilson v. Image Flooring (2013) and applied it in Midwest Trust v. UPS (2025).

What is the difference between negligent hiring and vicarious liability?

Vicarious liability, or respondeat superior, makes the company answer for its driver’s negligence while the driver is on the job, whether or not the company did anything wrong. Negligent hiring, retention, and entrustment are about the company’s own choices, such as hiring or keeping a driver it knew or should have known was dangerous. In Missouri, those direct claims still require the driver’s negligence to have caused the crash.

What is in a truck driver’s qualification file?

Under 49 CFR 391.51, the driver qualification file must include the driver’s employment application, motor vehicle records from each state licensing agency at hiring and from each annual inquiry, the road test certificate or accepted equivalent, a note on the annual review of the driving record, the medical examiner’s certificate (or for CDL holders, the state record showing medical certification status), and any medical variance or skill performance evaluation certificate. The file must be kept while the driver is employed and for 3 years after.

Does a trucking company have to check a driver’s record before hiring?

Yes. Under 49 CFR 391.23, a motor carrier must get the driver’s motor vehicle record from every state where the driver held a license in the past 3 years, and investigate the driver’s safety history with DOT-regulated employers over the past 3 years, generally within 30 days of hiring. Under 49 CFR 382.701, it must also query FMCSA’s Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse before the driver performs safety-sensitive work.

What is the FMCSA non-domiciled CDL rule?

FMCSA’s final rule, published February 13, 2026 (91 FR 7044) and effective March 16, 2026, limits who states may issue non-domiciled commercial learner’s permits and CDLs to. According to FMCSA’s guidance, only applicants with evidence of lawful immigration status in H-2A, H-2B, or E-2 status are eligible. The rule governs state licensing agencies under 49 CFR Parts 383 and 384.

Can I get punitive damages against a trucking company in Missouri?

Possibly, but the bar is high. RSMo 510.261 requires clear and convincing evidence that the defendant intentionally harmed the plaintiff without just cause or acted with a deliberate and flagrant disregard for others’ safety. An employer can be liable for punitive damages based on its driver’s conduct only in listed situations, including where the driver was unfit and the company was reckless in hiring or retaining him. A punitive claim can only be added with the court’s permission.

How long do I have to sue a trucking company in Missouri?

Most Missouri personal injury claims must be filed within five years under RSMo 516.120. Wrongful death claims generally must be filed within three years under RSMo 537.100. Some truck evidence, like electronic logging and camera data, may be kept for a much shorter time, so act early.

accident attorney in missouri

What Awards Has Our Personal Injury Lawyer Received?

At Mutrux Firm Injury Lawyers, our results speak through the voices of our clients and now, through the honors we’ve earned in the community. Tyson Mutrux is licensed to practice in Missouri, Illinois, and U.S. Federal Courts. He takes every case seriously, representing individuals in serious injury claims with precision and care.

A lawyer’s reputation speaks volumes about their ability to handle cases effectively. Whether you need legal representation for a personal injury claim, a car accident, a motorcycle accident, a truck or tow-truck accident, a pedestrian accident, a catastrophic injury, or a wrongful death, choosing an attorney with a proven track record is essential.

Mutrux Firm Injury Lawyers awards and recognition, including Expertise.com 2026 Best Car Accident Lawyers in Columbia, TrustAnalytica Top 10, Avvo 10.0 Superb, Top 40 Under 40 Trial Lawyers, National Trial Lawyers Top 100, and Super Lawyers.

Before Tyson Mutrux became a personal injury lawyer, he served in the U.S. Army as a Non-Commissioned Officer. He graduated with distinction from the Non-Commissioned Officers Academy and received the Army Commendation Medal for exceptional service.

The military taught him discipline, precision, and the importance of planning three moves ahead. Those same principles guide his approach to every case today.

Over the years, he has earned notable recognition, including:

  • Selected for Super Lawyers (2024 – 2026).
  • Best Car Accident Lawyer in Columbia, Missouri, Expertise.com (2026).
  • Best Injury Lawyer in Columbia, Inside Columbia Magazine (2025).
  • Top 10 Car Accident Lawyers in Columbia, Trust Analytica (2024).
  • The Nation’s Top One Percent of Attorneys, National Association of Distinguished Counsel (2015).
  • Top 100 and Top 40 Under 40, The National Trial Lawyers (2014).
  • Superb (10/10) Rating, Avvo (2012).
  • U.S. Army Commendation Medal.

You can also connect with us directly on Google to see reviews, updates, and more:

Mutrux Firm Injury Lawyers – St. Louis

Mutrux Firm Injury Lawyers – Columbia

We serve clients across Missouri and Illinois, with dedicated offices in St. Louis and Columbia.

mutrux law firm

The Driver’s File Is Where These Cases Are Won. Let Us Get It.

When a trucking company admits its driver was on the job, that isn’t the end of the fight, it’s often the start of the real one. The question becomes whether the company should have ever put that driver on the road, and the answer lives in a file the company would rather you never see. At Mutrux Firm Injury Lawyers, we move fast to name the right carrier, send the preservation letters that keep the logs, camera footage, and engine data from disappearing, and push for the discovery that shows what the company knew. We offer a free case review, and you pay nothing unless we win. Call (888) 550-4026 or contact us today, before the evidence that matters most is gone.

Suing the Trucking Company: Negligent Hiring and CDL Qualification in Missouri

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *