Skip to main content

Mutrux Firm Injury Lawyers

Personal Injury Settlement Lawyer

U.S. Army veteran and former State Farm claims representative, now fighting for injured people. Licensed in Missouri, Illinois and U.S. Federal Courts. No fees unless we win!

5-Star Rated on Google
Find Out if You Have a Case
Illustration of a drive-through window handoff, with a barista passing a cardboard carrier of three tall cups toward a waiting driver, one cup sitting askew

Burned by Hot Coffee or Tea at a Drive-Thru: Do You Have a Claim in Missouri?

Illustration of a drive-through window handoff, with a barista passing a cardboard carrier of three tall cups toward a waiting driver, one cup sitting askew
A loose cup in a carrier can turn a routine drive-thru stop into a serious burn. (Illustration, not a real restaurant.)

Short answer: You might. In Missouri, a burn from a hot drink at a drive-thru can be a negligence claim, a product liability claim, or both, depending on the facts. The question usually isn’t whether the coffee was hot. Of course it was hot. The question is whether the restaurant or the product was unreasonably dangerous in the way the drink was prepared, lidded, placed in a carrier, or handed to you, and whether that caused a serious burn. Missouri uses pure comparative fault. If you share some of the blame, your recovery is reduced by your percentage of fault. It isn’t automatically thrown out. A California jury’s $50 million verdict against Starbucks in 2025 doesn’t control a Missouri case. It does show that these claims can be about more than a spilled cup.

A California drive-thru verdict, and what it actually decided

In March 2025, a Los Angeles County jury awarded $50 million to Michael Garcia, a Postmates delivery driver. The Associated Press and the Los Angeles Times both reported the verdict.

According to the Times, the incident happened on February 8, 2020, at a Starbucks drive-through in Exposition Park. Garcia, then 25, was picking up three Venti hot teas in a cardboard drink carrier. During the handoff, two of the teas fell from the carrier, the lids came off, and the drinks spilled in his lap. He suffered severe burns, including to his genitals, and later had two skin grafts. The Times reviewed court documents describing lasting pain and sexual dysfunction. Garcia’s case included store video that, the Times said, appeared to show one of the large drinks sitting askew in the tray as a barista passed the order through the window. He claimed the lids were not securely fastened. Starbucks denied it was at fault and called the damages excessive. It said it planned to appeal.

Court records in the same case, Garcia v. Starbucks Corporation, Los Angeles Superior Court No. 20STCV10214, later show a Notice of Settlement of Entire Case filed June 20, 2025, and a Request for Dismissal filed July 14, 2025. Those filings do not state the settlement amount or the terms. So the public record of how a jury saw the case is still the $50 million verdict. What the parties later agreed to pay is not public.

That’s California. Missouri courts don’t have to follow it. The useful part is the fact pattern: a drink carrier, a loose cup or lid, a handoff at a window, and a serious burn.

Illustration of a car seat with a cardboard drink carrier and a tipped paper cup spilling hot coffee or tea onto the fabric, steam rising
The claim is usually about the lid, the carrier, or the handoff, not the fact that the drink was hot. (Illustration.)

Negligence vs. product liability in Missouri

Most drive-thru burn cases start as ordinary negligence. Did the employee use reasonable care when they filled the cup, put the lid on, set it in the carrier, and handed it over? If the cup was sitting crooked in the tray, or the lid wasn’t seated, that’s a negligence question about how the drink was served.

Sometimes the product itself is the problem. A lid that doesn’t stay on. A carrier that collapses. A cup that fails in ordinary use. Missouri’s product liability statute, RSMo 537.760, lets you sue a seller in the chain of commerce if:

  • the defendant transferred the product in the course of its business,
  • the product was used in a reasonably anticipated way, and
  • the product was in a defective condition unreasonably dangerous when put to a reasonably anticipated use, or it was unreasonably dangerous without an adequate warning.

You don’t have to prove the company was careless on a strict liability theory. You do have to prove the defect and that it caused your injury. We walk through that framework on our St. Louis product liability page, and in more detail in our post on exploding container claims. If the problem is how the store ran the window, not the cup itself, the claim may look more like a premises liability case about unsafe conditions or careless service on the property.

Temperature can matter, but it’s the easiest part of these cases to overstate. Coffee and tea are supposed to be hot. A claim that rests only on “it burned me, so it was too hot” is a weak claim. A stronger claim usually has more: a lid or carrier that failed, a handoff that wasn’t secure, or a warning that didn’t match a genuinely unreasonably dangerous temperature.

Comparative fault, including in product cases

The defense in a spill case will often say you share the blame. You were driving. You didn’t wait to check the lid. You set the carrier down wrong.

Missouri abolished contributory negligence as a complete defense in ordinary tort cases in Gustafson v. Benda, 661 S.W.2d 11 (Mo. banc 1983). The Missouri Supreme Court adopted pure comparative fault. If you’re 20% at fault, your damages are reduced by 20%. You’re not barred from recovering just because you weren’t perfect.

Product claims have their own statute for this. RSMo 537.765 says contributory fault is not a complete bar in a products liability claim, and pure comparative fault applies. But “fault” in that section is limited to a short list, including using the product in a way the manufacturer wouldn’t reasonably anticipate, using it for an unintended purpose, voluntarily and unreasonably exposing yourself to a known danger, failing to take the precautions a reasonably careful user would take, and failing to mitigate damages.

That list is narrower than general negligence comparative fault. Whether a particular spill is a product case, a negligence case, or both, and which fault rules apply, is something that has to be worked out from the facts. It’s not automatic.

The McDonald’s coffee case, without the folklore

People still talk about Stella Liebeck. A lot of what they remember is wrong.

Liebeck was 79 when she was burned in 1992. She was in a parked car at a McDonald’s drive-through. She put the cup between her knees and tried to take the lid off, and the coffee spilled in her lap. She suffered third-degree burns on her legs, groin, and buttocks and needed skin grafts. In 1994, a New Mexico jury awarded her $160,000 in compensatory damages and $2.7 million in punitive damages. A judge later cut the punitive award to $480,000, leaving a total of $640,000, according to contemporaneous Associated Press reporting in the Los Angeles Times. The parties later settled. The terms were confidential.

That’s the actual record. It wasn’t a woman driving down the road with a cup in her lap and walking away a millionaire. It also isn’t a Missouri case, and it doesn’t set a Missouri damages number. I’m including it only because it’s the story everybody reaches for, and the real numbers are smaller and more complicated than the myth.

What to do if this happened to you?

  • Get medical care the same day. Burns can look milder than they are at first, and the medical record is the backbone of the claim.
  • Keep the cup, the lid, and the carrier if you still have them. Don’t wash them. Put them in a bag. Photograph the scene, the seat, your clothing, and the injuries as they appear.
  • Get the store to make a report, and ask for any video. Drive-thru cameras get overwritten. Ask promptly.
  • Write down what happened while you remember it. Who handed you the drink, whether the lid felt loose, whether a cup was sitting crooked, and how soon it spilled.
  • Don’t throw away the clothes you were wearing.

Most Missouri personal injury claims, including product claims, have to be filed within five years under RSMo 516.120. Wrongful death claims generally have three years under RSMo 537.100. In a burn case, you want the physical evidence long before either of those dates.

If this happened to you, you can use the form on this page to find out if you have a case.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have a lawsuit if I was burned by hot coffee at a Missouri drive-thru?

Possibly, if you can show the restaurant or the product was negligent or defective, and that this caused a serious burn. The fact that coffee is hot is not enough by itself. Facts that tend to matter include a lid that wasn’t secured, a cup sitting crooked in a carrier, a carrier that failed, or a genuinely inadequate warning about an unreasonably dangerous temperature.

Is a hot-coffee burn a product liability case or a negligence case in Missouri?

It can be either, or both. Negligence focuses on how the drink was prepared and handed over. Product liability under RSMo 537.760 focuses on whether the cup, lid, or carrier was defective or lacked an adequate warning. The right theory depends on the evidence.

What if the restaurant says the spill was my fault?

Missouri follows pure comparative fault. Under Gustafson v. Benda, your recovery is reduced by your share of fault, not wiped out. In a products claim, RSMo 537.765 applies the same idea, but it limits what counts as the plaintiff’s “fault.” Sharing some blame does not automatically end the case.

Does the $50 million Starbucks verdict mean I have a similar case in Missouri?

No. That was a California jury verdict in March 2025 in Garcia v. Starbucks. It doesn’t control Missouri law or Missouri damages. The later court filings show the parties notified the court that the case had settled, and a request for dismissal was filed, without a public settlement amount. What the verdict does show is that a drive-thru handoff, a loose cup, and a serious burn can be a real injury case.

How long do I have to file a claim in Missouri?

Most personal injury claims must be filed within five years under RSMo 516.120. Wrongful death claims generally have three years under RSMo 537.100. Video, the cup, and the lid can be gone in days, so the practical deadline is much shorter.

Burned by More Than Just Hot Coffee? Let’s Look at the Real Cause.

A serious burn from a drive-thru drink is rarely about the fact that coffee is hot, it’s about the lid that wasn’t seated, the cup sitting crooked in the carrier, or the handoff that was never secure. Those are the details that turn a spilled cup into a real claim, and they’re also the details that vanish fastest: the video gets overwritten, the cup and carrier get tossed, the burn heals before anyone documents how bad it was. At Mutrux Firm Injury Lawyers, we move quickly to preserve that evidence, figure out whether your case is negligence, product liability, or both, and press for the full value of what a serious burn actually costs you. Missouri’s pure comparative fault rule means sharing a little blame doesn’t end your claim, so don’t let an insurer talk you out of one. We offer a free case review, and you pay nothing unless we win. Call (888) 550-4026 or contact us today.

Burned by Hot Coffee or Tea at a Drive-Thru: Do You Have a Claim in Missouri?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *